Current:Home > ScamsPhilly teachers sue district for First Amendment rights violation over protests -NextFrontier Finance
Philly teachers sue district for First Amendment rights violation over protests
View
Date:2025-04-12 10:38:40
Three Philadelphia school teachers filed a proposed class action lawsuit on August 18 against the School District of Philadelphia, accusing the district of violating their First Amendment rights after they protested against asbestos in the school.
Ethan Tannen and Carolyn Gray, who are current teachers at Julia R. Masterman Laboratory and Demonstration School along with Karen Celli, who retired in June 2023, claim in a lawsuit obtained by ABC News that the school docked their pay for unauthorized absences after they assembled their workstations on the outdoor patio of the school amid concerns over asbestos in the facilities.
The complaint alleges that the district failed to provide complete information to teachers and parents about asbestos remediation efforts and potential dangers of asbestos at the school.
The school district marked the teachers as absent and docked their pay for Aug. 26 and 27, according to the complaint.
"Those teachers were not 'absent'. The district knew that and knew they were working," Mary Catherine Roper, an attorney who represents all three teachers, said to ABC News in a statement on Sept. 13. "The district wanted to stop the protest, so they threatened the teachers and then punished them. That violates the First Amendment."
The School District of Philadelphia told ABC News in a statement that they could not comment on pending litigation. They also would not elaborate on whether asbestos exists at the Masterman school.
The latest AHERA (Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act) report published for the Masterman school building, which is from the 2018-2019 school year, identified over 100 "confirmed" or "assumed" sources of asbestos in the building, according to the lawsuit.
MORE: Hard choices face teacher and some parents as school district struggles with asbestos
"Asbestos is a naturally occurring fibrous material that has historically been used for many industrial and construction purposes," said Dr. Stephanie Widmer, an ABC News contributor and medical toxicologist, who was not involved in this case. "The material itself is very fire resistant and is a great thermal insulator, many houses built before 1980 contained asbestos. Since the discovery of negative health effects, 66 countries and territories have banned asbestos."
Though asbestos' use is now limited in the United States, it is not completely banned, Widmer said.
"Well established health risks of asbestos exposure include 'asbestosis', which is scarring of the lungs that results from inhaling asbestos fibers, and an aggressive form of lung cancer, Mesothelioma," Widmer said. "Asbestos is a known carcinogen."
According to Widmer, it is important to note that negative health effects from asbestos exposure don’t mount right away. It can take many years to develop illness.
MORE: FDA finds asbestos in makeup at Claire’s
The issue of asbestos in schools is one that the School District of Philadelphia has dealt with over the years. Two schools had to close last April due to concerns of the presence of the potentially hazardous mineral fiber.
Amid school closures, School District of Philadelphia superintendent Tony Watlington told ABC News in April that it would cost almost $5 billion to "fully repair and bring our buildings up to code."
"With decades of underfunding, the district has had to balance insufficient resources to work on our facilities and the need to deliver pressing educational services," Watlington added.
To curb the effects of asbestos in schools, Congress passed the Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act in 1986, ordering districts "to inspect their school buildings for asbestos-containing building material, prepare asbestos management plans and perform asbestos response actions to prevent or reduce asbestos hazards," according to the Brookings Institute, a non-profit public policy organization in Washington D.C.
Research has shown that lower-income and minority communities are disproportionally impacted by asbestos exposure, similar to other environmental pollutants compared to their wealthier, white counterparts because these groups are more likely to live in places or work in jobs that have environmental and occupational exposure.
"The class members suffered damage as a result of the district’s retaliatory actions in the form of a loss of First Amendment freedoms, lost wages and other employment benefits, and damage to their professional reputations from the discipline recorded in their employment records," according to the teachers' complaint.
According to the lawsuit, up to 50 teachers were improperly disciplined. The three educators are seeking an award of financial damages from lost wages, plus interest and an expungement of their employment records from the school district's disciplinary actions.
ABC News' Jade Cobern contributed to this report.
veryGood! (96755)
Related
- Taylor Swift Eras Archive site launches on singer's 35th birthday. What is it?
- A 376-pound alligator was behaving strangely at a Florida zoo. Doctors figured out why.
- Yellow is shutting down after 99 years. Here's what happened.
- An economic argument for heat safety regulation (Encore)
- Federal appeals court upholds $14.25 million fine against Exxon for pollution in Texas
- Pac-12 leaders receive details of media deal, but no vote to accept terms as future remains murky
- 'Home Improvement' star Zachery Ty Bryan arrested for domestic violence (again)
- Looking to transfer jobs within the same company? How internal transfers work: Ask HR
- Man can't find second winning lottery ticket, sues over $394 million jackpot, lawsuit says
- Taco Bell sued over amount of meat, beans in Mexican pizzas, crunch wraps
Ranking
- DeepSeek: Did a little known Chinese startup cause a 'Sputnik moment' for AI?
- The first generation of solar panels will wear out. A recycling industry is taking shape
- Flashing 'X' sign on top of Twitter building in San Francisco sparks city investigation
- Watch a fire whirl vortex race across the Mojave Desert as a massive wildfire rages through the West
- Mets have visions of grandeur, and a dynasty, with Juan Soto as major catalyst
- After the death of his wife, actor Richard E. Grant vowed to find joy every day
- 22-month-old girl killed after dresser tips over, trapping her
- What’s an SUV? The confusion won't end any time soon.
Recommendation
The Best Stocking Stuffers Under $25
Russia accuses Ukraine of a drone attack on Moscow that hit the same building just days ago
Mother of former missing Arizona teen asks the public to move on in new video
Hawaii could see a big hurricane season, but most homes aren’t ready
Megan Fox's ex Brian Austin Green tells Machine Gun Kelly to 'grow up'
Trader Joe's recalls broccoli cheddar soup, frozen falafel for containing bugs and rocks
Vegas man killed roommate and lived with her corpse for extended period of time, police say
Paul Reubens, Pee-wee Herman actor and comedian, dies at 70 after private cancer battle