Current:Home > InvestAmid Drought, Wealthy Homeowners in New Mexico are Getting a Tax Break to Water Their Lawns -NextFrontier Finance
Amid Drought, Wealthy Homeowners in New Mexico are Getting a Tax Break to Water Their Lawns
View
Date:2025-04-17 19:39:56
A New Mexico law providing a tax break meant to help subsistence farming throughout the state has also been granted to “hobby farmers” and wealthy landowners who don’t farm at all and use water meant for crop irrigation on what are expansive yards in the state’s most populous county, according to a study published last week by the University of New Mexico School of Law’s Natural Resources Journal.
So-called greenbelt laws were passed around the country during the 20th century to help contain urban sprawl and preserve agricultural land. New Mexico passed its own in 1967, helping preserve green spaces statewide and in Bernalillo County, home to Albuquerque, through the tax break to non-commercial farming operations.
But the law has enabled some landowners to receive the tax break while not meeting the criteria for subsistence farming, according to the paper. Meanwhile, the county government that administers the tax break doesn’t cooperate in its oversight with the local water district, which has failed to consider water usage meant for agriculture under the tax break by those who are not engaged in subsistence farming, a crucial concern given the ongoing drought in the Southwest, the paper said.
“We, as communities, through our state legislature, our county governments and our water agencies, need to think carefully about the suite of laws that we have and whether they are sufficient to help us adapt to climate change, or whether they are maladaptive,” said John Fleck, a coauthor of the study and a water policy expert at the University of New Mexico School of Law’s Utton Center.
The paper found that about a quarter of land parcels that received the tax break were enrolled in the Middle Rio Grande Conservancy District’s irrigation system. In 2020, the researchers estimated that resulted in 4,388 acres of land in the county using 11,000 acre-feet of water. “This is equivalent to nearly a quarter of the county’s entire 2020 municipal water use, enough for approximately 40,000 homes,” the study’s authors wrote.
Receiving an agricultural evaluation from the county under the greenbelt law saves landowners an average of $1,608 on their property tax bills, the paper found, and has helped preserve green spaces throughout the region that likely would not exist without the law.
But nowhere does the statute require tracking of the water needed to support what are supposed to be subsistence farming operations. “The County reports that it tracks the tax program but not related water usage, and the District reports that it manages irrigation but does not consider the tax program,” they wrote. Unlike many irrigation districts in the country, Fleck said, the Middle Rio Grande Conservancy District does not have the ability to track the actual volume of water each property uses.
“It is no longer responsible stewardship for policies that affect water resources to avoid scrutiny, as New Mexico’s future planning and resiliency efforts move further into an era of aridification and shrinking water supplies,” they wrote.
Getting the tax break is “determined on the basis of the land’s capacity to produce agricultural products,” according to the law. Court cases involving the statute, the paper’s authors wrote, ruled that those enrolled in it should be using the land for subsistence farming, defined by the National Agricultural Library as a “farming system where the food and goods produced are predominantly consumed by the farm family and there is little surplus for sale in the market.”
But the paper found instances of properties receiving the tax break without meeting the criteria, as defined by the statute itself, as well as in court rulings or municipal regulations. Through analyzing data from the Middle Rio Grande Conservancy District and the county, the authors found 101 properties receiving the tax break and using irrigation water on what the Middle Rio Grande Conservancy District calls their “yards.”
To confirm the findings, Fleck and Annalise Porter, the study’s lead author and a graduate of UNM’s Water Resources Program, visited some locations and “found a combination of straight-up yards” and properties with crops like crops alfalfa that were mislabeled, Porter said.
Fleck took extensive bicycle tours around Albuquerque, he said, where he found neighborhoods with lush yards and trees where homeowners were receiving the agricultural tax break. “My bike riding was crucial to this process,” he said.
He spoke to a homeowner in a yard and learned that the man watered the yard from an irrigation ditch behind the home, which led the team to look into yards receiving both the irrigation water and the tax break.
They found that some of the yards receiving tax breaks fell within the boundaries of the Village of Los Rancho, an affluent community in Albuquerque’s North Valley which had 219 total properties with the agricultural valuation in 2018. “This, and the mere existence of the ‘yard category,’ lend to the assertion that the tax program may not be currently used as was originally intended by legislature,” the authors wrote.
Porter said the law is just one example of the siloed thinking lawmakers often exhibit when constructing policy in complex areas involving land use and water rights. The state’s greenbelt law is written as tax policy, but also touches on water usage and urban growth.
Porter and Fleck agreed the law is well-intentioned, but communities must reevaluate the tax break and related use of water intended for crop irrigation to address heat, drought and water scarcity related to the climate crisis.
The irrigated water some of the parcels receive comes from the Rio Grande, which ran dry in Albuquerque for the first time in four decades this past summer. The state also relies on water from the Colorado River, which is in the midst of more than 20 years of drought. Recent negotiations over Colorado water rights resulted in tensions among stakeholders over how to save a system that powers millions of homes across the Southwest and has helped fuel growth in the region with its water.
“There’s less water because of climate change,” Fleck said. “And that means there will be less green.”
veryGood! (6298)
Related
- Backstage at New York's Jingle Ball with Jimmy Fallon, 'Queer Eye' and Meghan Trainor
- Online retailer eBay is cutting 1,000 jobs. It’s the latest tech company to reduce its workforce
- Civil war turned Somalia’s main soccer stadium into an army camp. Now it’s hosting games again
- Trial of Land Defenders Fighting the Coastal GasLink Pipeline is Put on Hold as Canadian Police Come Under Scrutiny for Excessive Force
- Questlove charts 50 years of SNL musical hits (and misses)
- Biden sending senior West Wing aides Mike Donilon, Jennifer O'Malley Dillon to oversee 2024 reelection campaign
- Several injured after 7.1-magnitude earthquake hits part of western China
- Love Is Blind's Marshall Glaze Is Engaged to Chay Barnes
- NHL in ASL returns, delivering American Sign Language analysis for Deaf community at Winter Classic
- India's Modi inaugurates huge Ayodhya Ram Temple on one of Hinduism's most revered but controversial sites
Ranking
- Appeals court scraps Nasdaq boardroom diversity rules in latest DEI setback
- Baby names we could see vanish this year and those blazing ahead in 2024
- New Jersey Supreme Court rules against Ocean casino in COVID business interruption case
- Swiss financial regulator gets a new leader as UBS-Credit Suisse merger sparks calls for reform
- How to watch new prequel series 'Dexter: Original Sin': Premiere date, cast, streaming
- Myanmar’s army denies that generals were sentenced to death for surrendering key city to insurgents
- Collision of gas truck and car in Mongolian capital kills at least 6 and injures 11
- Factory never tested applesauce packets that were recalled due to lead poisonings, FDA finds
Recommendation
Paula Abdul settles lawsuit with former 'So You Think You Can Dance' co
Americans’ economic outlook brightens as inflation slows and wages outpace prices
Andy Cohen Sets the Record Straight on Monica Garcia's RHOSLC Future
New Jersey Supreme Court rules against Ocean casino in COVID business interruption case
How to watch new prequel series 'Dexter: Original Sin': Premiere date, cast, streaming
Indiana man convicted in fatal 2021 shootings of a woman, her young daughter and fiancé
Maryland appeals court throws out murder conviction of former US intelligence director’s daughter
Why did 'The Bachelor' blur the Canadian flag? Maria Georgas's arrival gift censored